FEDERAL MINE SAFETY AND HEALTH REVIEW COMMISSION

Office of Administrative Law Judges

601 New Jersey Avenue, N.W., Suite 9500

Washington, DC 20001-2021

Telephone: (202) 434-9980 / Fax: (202) 434-9949

July 22, 2013

SECRETARY OF LABOR,    MINE SAFETY AND HEALTH     ADMINISTRATION (MSHA),   Petitioner, v. MANALAPAN MINING COMPANY ET AL., Respondent.

: : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

CIVIL PENALTY PROCEEDINGS: Docket No. KENT 2009-240 A.C. No. 15-04331-166529-02 Q7G Mine: Prep Plant Docket No. KENT 2009-562 A.C. No. 15-19102-172530 Q7G Mine: Prep Plant Docket No. KENT 2009-1281 A.C. No. 15-17077-188288 Mine: RB #5 Docket No. KENT 2009-1284 A.C. No. 15-18771-188304 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2009-1286 A.C. No. 15-19102-191269 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2009-1388 A.C. No. 15-19102-191269 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2009-1549 A.C. No. 15-18145- 195699 Mine: CM & E No. 3 Docket No. KENT 2009-1601 A.C. No. 15-18771-197255 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2010-9 A.C. No. 15-19102-197266-01 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2010-10 A.C. No. 15-19102-197266-02 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2010- 148 A.C. No. 15-17077- 200396 Mine: RB #5 Docket No. KENT 2010-152 A.C. No. 15-19102- 200414-02 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2010-767 A.C. No. 15-18145-211556 Mine: CM & E #3 Docket No. KENT 2010-918 A.C. No. 15-19102-214185 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2010-1024 A.C. No. 15-18771-217566 Q7G Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2010-1108 A.C. No. 15-17077-219606 Mine: RB #5 Docket No. KENT 2010-1211 A.C. No. 15-18771-222910-01 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2010-1212 A.C. No. 15-18771-222910-02 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2010-1213 A.C. No. 15-19102-222918-01 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2010-1214 A.C. No. 15-19102-222918-02 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2010-1362 A.C. No. 15-17077-225927 Mine: RB #5 Docket No. KENT 2010-1364 A.C. No. 15-18771-225937-02 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2010-1365 A.C. No. 15-18771-225937 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2010-1436 A.C. No. 1518771-226595 Q7G Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2010-1514 A.C. No. 15-17077-229388 Mine: RB #5 Docket No. KENT 2010-1515 A.C. No. 15-18771-229396-01 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2010-1516 A.C. No. 15-18771-229396-02 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2010-1517 A.C. No. 15-19102-229401-01 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2010-1518 A.C. No. 15-19102-229401-02 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2010-1648 A.C. No. 15-17077-232523 Mine: RB #5 Docket No. KENT 2010-1649 A.C. No. 15-18771-232531-01 Mine: RB#12 Docket No. KENT 2010-1650 A.C. No. 15-18771-232531 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2010-1651 A.C. No. 15-19102-232534 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2011-143 A.C. No. 15-17077-235588 Mine: RB #5 Docket No. KENT 2011-144 A.C. No. 15-19514-235613-01 Mine: D-1 Mine Docket No. KENT 2011-145 A.C. No. 15-19514-235613-02 Mine: D-1 Mine Docket No. KENT 2011-154 A.C. No. 15-18771-235595-01 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2011-155 A.C. No. 15-18771-235595-02 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2011-156 A.C. No. 15-19102-235600 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2011-349 A.C. No. 15-18771-238738 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2011-347 A.C. No. 15-04331-238717 Mine: Prep Plant Docket No. KENT 2011-348 A.C. No. 15-17077- 238728 Mine: RB #5 Docket No. KENT 2011-350 A.C. No. 15-19102-238745 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2011-446 A.C. No. 15-18771-241670 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2011-447 A.C. No. 15-19102-241673 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2011-448 A.C. No. 15-19514-241685 Mine: D-1 Mine Docket No. KENT 2011-559 A.C. No. 15-17077-244188-01 Mine: RB #5 Docket No. KENT 2011-560 A.C. No. 15-17077-244188-02 Mine: RB #5 Docket No. KENT 2011-561 A.C. No. 15-18771-244196-01 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2011-562 A.C. No. 15-18771-244196-02 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2011-563 A.C. No. 15-19102-244202 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2011-564 A.C. No. 15-19514-244212 Mine: D-1 Mine Docket No. KENT 2011-680 A.C. No. 15-17077-247063 Mine: RB #5 Docket No. KENT 2011-681 A.C. No. 15-18771-247071-01 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2011-682 A.C. No. 15-18771-247071-02 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2011-683 A.C. No. 15-19102-247077 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2011-684 A.C. No. 15-19514-247093 Mine: D-1 Docket No. KENT 2011-795 A.C. No. 15-19498-249244 Mine: Putney #1 Docket No. KENT 2011-817 A.C. No. 15-19514-249636 Mine: D-1 Docket No. KENT 2011-823 A.C. No. 15-18771-249620 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2011-824 A.C. No. 15-19102-249626 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2011-947 A.C. No. 15-04331-252258 Mine: Prep Plant Docket No. KENT 2011-948 A.C. No. 15-17077-252265 Mine: RB #5 Docket No. KENT 2011-949 A.C. No. 15-18771-252271-01 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2011-950 A.C. No. 15-18771-252271-02 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2011-951 A.C. No. 15-19102-252275 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2011-952 A.C. No. 15-19514-252288 Mine: D-1 Mine Docket No. KENT 2011-991 A.C. No. 15-04331-250045 Q7G Mine: Prep Plant Docket No. KENT 2011-992 A.C. No. 15-19102-250080 Q7G Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2011-1053 A.C. No. 15-04331-252712 Q7G Mine: Prep Plant Docket No. KENT 2011-1128 A.C. No. 15-18771-255530-01 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2011-1129 A.C. No. 15-18771-255530-02 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2011-1130 A.C. No. 15-19514-255548 Mine: D-1 Mine Docket No. KENT 2011-1132 A.C. No. 15-04331-255517 Mine: Prep Plant Docket No. KENT 2011-1133 A.C. No. 15-19102-255536 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2011-1151 A.C. No. 15-04331-256021 Q7G Mine: Prep Plant Docket No. KENT 2011-1234 A.C. No. 15-18771-258422 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2011-1235 A.C. No. 15-19514-258436 Mine: D-1 Mine Docket No. KENT 2011-1236 A.C. No. 15-04331-258408 Mine: Prep Plant Docket No. KENT 2011-1237 A.C. No. 15-19102-258428 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2011-1332 A.C. No. 15-04331-261013 Mine: Prep Plant Docket No. KENT 2011-1333 A.C. No. 15-17077-261016 Mine: RB #5 Docket No. KENT 2011-1334 A.C. No. 15-18771-261023-01 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2011-1335 A.C. No. 15-18771-261023-02 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2011-1336 A.C. No. 15-19102-261029-01 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2011-1337 A.C. No. 15-19102-261029-02 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2011-1342 A.C. No. 15-19514-261034 Mine: D-1 Mine Docket No. KENT 2011-1343 A.C. No. 15-19498-260559 Mine: No. 1 Docket No. KENT 2011-1375 A.C. No. 15-19102-261444 Q7G Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2011-1493 A.C. No. 15-04331-264087 Mine: Prep Plant Docket No. KENT 2011-1494 A.C. No. 15-17077-264095 Mine: RB #5 Docket No. KENT 2011-1495 A.C. No. 15-18771-264105-01 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2011-1496 A.C. No. 15-18771-264105-02 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2011-1497 A.C. No. 15-19102-264112-01 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2011-1498 A.C. No. 15-19102-264112-02 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2012-20 A.C. No. 15-18771-267096-01 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2012-21 A.C. No. 15-18771-267096-02 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2012-22 A.C. No. 15-19102-267100 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2012-23 A.C. No. 15-19514-267106-01 Mine: D-1 Mine Docket No. KENT 2012-24 A.C. No. 15-19514-267106-02 Mine: D-1 Mine Docket No. KENT 2012-137 A.C. No. 15-04331-269815 Mine: Prep Plant Docket No. KENT 2012-138 A.C. No. 15-17077-269818 Mine: RB #5 Docket No. KENT 2012-139 A.C. No. 15-18771-269824 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2012-140 A.C. No. 15-19102-269827-01 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2012-141 A.C. No. 15-19102-269827-02 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2012-142 A.C. No. 15-19514-269835 Mine: D-1 Mine Docket No. KENT 2012-320 A.C. No. 15-04331-272673 Mine: Prep Plant Docket No. KENT 2012-321 A.C. No. 15-18771-272686 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2012-322 A.C. No. 15-19102-272691 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2012-323 A.C. No. 15-19514-272697 Mine: D-1 Docket No. KENT 2012-413 A.C. No. 15-17077-275502 Mine: RB #5 Docket No. KENT 2012-414 A.C. No. 15-18771-275508 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2012-415 A.C. No. 15-19102-275513-01 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2012-416 A.C. No. 15-19102-275513-02 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2012-639 A.C. No. 15-19498-280617 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2012-723 A.C. No. 15-04331-281023 Mine: Prep Plant Docket No. KENT 2012-724 A.C. No. 15-17077-281027 Mine: RB #5 Docket No. KENT 2012-725 A.C. No. 15-18771-281032-01 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2012-726 A.C. No. 15-18771-281032-02 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2012-728 A.C. No. 15-19102-281035-02 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2012-729 A.C. No. 15-19514-281038 Mine: D-1 Mine Docket No. KENT 2012-839 A.C. No. 15-04331-283662 Mine: Prep Plant Docket No. KENT 2012-840 A.C. No. 15-17077-283671 Mine: RB #5 Docket No. KENT 2012-841 A.C. No. 15-19102-283682-01 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2012-842 A.C. No. 15-19102-283682-02 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2012-845 A.C. No. 15-18771-283677-01 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2012-846 A.C. No. 15-18771-283677-02 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2012-847 A.C. No. 15-18771-283677-03 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2012-848 A.C. No. 15-19514-283689-01 Mine: D-1 Mine Docket No. KENT 2012-849 A.C. No. 15-19514-283689-02 Mine: D-1 Mine Docket No. KENT 2012-885 A.C. No. 15-19102-284511 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2012-972 A.C. No. 15-04331-286805 Mine: Prep Plant Docket No. KENT 2012-973 A.C. No. 15-19514-286826 Mine: D-1 Mine Docket No. KENT 2012-974 A.C. No. 15-19514-286826-02 Mine: D-1 Mine Docket No. KENT 2012-1394 A.C. No. 15-18725-295419 Mine: RB #11 Docket No. KENT 2012-1499 A.C. No. 15-19102-298192 Mine: P-1 Docket No. KENT 2012-1501 A.C. No. 15-18771-298189 Mine: RB #12 Docket No. KENT 2013-17 A.C. No. 15-19514-300891-01 Mine: D-1 Docket No. KENT 2013-18 A.C. No. 15-19514-300891-02 Mine: D-1 Docket No. KENT 2013-352 A.C. No. 15-19102-309285 Mine: P-1

DECISION

Before: Judge David F. Barbour

Appearances: Amanda Slater, Esq., U.S. Department of Labor, Office of the Solicitor, Denver, Colorado

Schean Belton, Esq., U.S. Department of Labor, Office of the Solicitor, Nashville, Tennessee

John Williams, Esq., Rajkovich, Williams, Kilpatrick & True, PLLC, Lexington, Kentucky

Benjamin Bennett, 10156 US Hwy 25E, Pineville, Kentucky 40977

Jim Brummett, Jim Brummett, Manalapan Mining Company, Inc., 8174 E. Hwy 72, Pathfork, Kentucky 40863

The above-captioned cases are before me upon petitions for assessment of a civil penalty under section 105(d) of the Federal Mine Safety and Health Act of 1977. This matter, consolidated under lead Docket No. KENT 2009-1097, consists of 137 cases containing 982 citations and orders involving Manalapan Mining Company Inc. (“Manalapan”), B&S Trucking Company and Cloverfork Mining & Excavating, collectively referred to as Manalapan et al. The companies share common ownership and Manalapan is the Respondent for the majority of the cases.

On May 01, 2012, the parties jointly moved that all of the Respondents’ cases pending before the Commission be consolidated to facilitate settlement negotiations and evaluation of the Respondents’ claim that payment of the penalties proposed by the Secretary would affect its ability to continue in business. The cases were consolidated and set for hearing on October 16, 2012 in Lexington, Kentucky.

In a status update to the court, the Secretary[1] reported that the parties were unable to reach an agreement regarding the effect of the proposed penalties on the Respondents’ ability to continue in business, and that, as a result, settlement negotiations were unable to progress. The parties jointly requested that the court rule on whether the proposed penalties would affect the Respondents’ ability to continue in business and hold a hearing on the other civil penalty criteria and the fact of violation at a later date. Accordingly, the court scheduled a bifurcated hearing. Hearing I, which solely addressed the Respondents’ ability to continue in business, was scheduled to take place telephonically on December 13, 2012. Any cases not settled during subsequent settlement discussions were scheduled to be heard during Hearing II, in

January 2013.

During a subsequent conference call with the court, Respondents’ counsel reported that his clients were no longer alleging that the proposed penalties would affect their ability to continue in business. The Respondents’ counsel restated this point on the record during the telephonic hearing on December 13, 2012. The parties also requested additional time to discuss settlement. They stated that the focus of their prior discussions had been the Respondents’ ability to continue in business and that, as a result, they had little opportunity to engage in substantive settlement discussions. The cases were rescheduled to be heard March 05 - 15, 2013, and April 09 - 19, 2013, in Lexington, Kentucky. On February 11, 2013, the parties reported that they had made significant progress in their global settlement negotiations and requested additional time to conduct in person settlement discussions. On February 15, 2013, the court issued an order, which granted the parties additional time to negotiate and rescheduled the hearing for any outstanding dockets for April 09 - 12, 2013, April 15 - 19, 2013, June 04 - 06, 2013 and June 25 - 28, 2013. FIn the order, the court also granted the motion filed by Respondents’ counsel to withdraw as counsel of record, with his clients’ consent, due to their inability to pay additional attorneys’ fees. The Respondents proceeded pro se and Benjamin Bennett, President of Manalapan Mining Company, represented the Respondents in the global settlement negotiations that took place March 04-05, 2013, March 07-08, 2013 and March 11-13, 2013, in Pineville, Kentucky.[2] Steven Spitzer, attorney-advisor to Judge Jacqueline R. Bulluck, was available via phone to assist the parties as a settlement attorney. On March 13, 2013, the parties reported that settlement negotiations had been successful and that only 62 citations and orders remained. They requested that the hearing scheduled for April 09 - 12, 2013 be cancelled and that the parties be permitted to use April 15-19, 2013, originally reserved for a hearing, to conduct additional global settlement negotiations. The court granted the request. A subsequent conference call to discuss the outcome of settlement negotiations was scheduled and the remaining cases were set for hearing June 04 - 06, 2013.

During a status call on May 14, 2013, the parties reported that all but nine violations contained in three dockets, KENT 2009-1097, KENT 2010-1363 and KENT 2012-727, had been settled out of the original group of 143 dockets. A related docket, KENT 2012-1133, was consolidated with the three remaining dockets. The four cases were heard beginning

June 04, 2013. The parties were directed to file briefs with the court by September 03, 2013.

The Secretary has filed motions to approve the global settlement to which the Respondents have agreed. Total proposed penalty assessment amount was $1,994,395.00. The total proposed settlement amount is $1,197,365.00.

I have considered the representations and documentation submitted in these cases, and I conclude that the proffered settlement is appropriate under the criteria set forth in section 110(i) of the Act. The settlement terms are set forth below:

Citation/Order No.	Modification to Citation	Proposed Penalty	Amended Penalty
KENT 2009-1281
8335781	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8335782	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8335783	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,026.00	$ 800.00
8335784	Penalty Reduction	$ 362.00	$ 200.00
8335785	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 1,530.00	$ 1,400.00
8335786	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 634.00	$ 500.00
8335787	Penalty Reduction	$ 108.00	$ 100.00
8335788	Penalty Reduction	$ 499.00	$ 300.00
8335789	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8335790	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 1,795.00	$ 1,600.00
8335791	Penalty Reduction	$ 745.00	$ 600.00
8335792	Penalty Reduction	$ 108.00	$ 100.00
8335793	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8335794	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8335798	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 425.00	$ 300.00
8335799	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8335800	Penalty Reduction	$ 425.00	$ 300.00
8335801	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8225802	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 425.00	$ 300.00
8225803	Penalty Reduction	$ 425.00	$ 300.00
8335804	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8335812	Penalty Reduction	$ 425.00	$ 300.00
8335813	Penalty Reduction	$ 425.00	$ 300.00
8335814	Penalty Reduction	$ 425.00	$ 300.00
8335815	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 425.00	$ 300.00
8335819	Penalty Reduction	$ 425.00	$ 300.00
	Sub-Total	$11,432.00	$ 9,100.00
KENT 2009-1284
8334580	Modify to Low Negligence	$ 807.00	$ 400.00
8334581	Vacate	$ 2,473.00	$ 0.00
8334582	No Change	$ 190.00	$ 190.00
8334583	Penalty Reduction	$ 745.00	$ 376.00
8338394	No Change	$ 224.00	$ 224.00
8338395	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,203.00	$ 800.00
8334584	No Change	$ 150.00	$ 150.00
8338396	No Change	$ 150.00	$ 150.00
8334585	No Change	$ 150.00	$ 150.00
8334586	No Change	$ 150.00	$ 150.00
8334590	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 745.00	$ 350.00
8334591	No Change	$ 745.00	$ 745.00
8334592	No Change	$ 150.00	$ 150.00
8334593	No Change	$ 150.00	$ 150.00
8334594	Penalty Reduction	$ 873.00	$ 348.00
8403423	No Change	$ 334.00	$ 334.00
8403425	No Change	$ 873.00	$ 873.00
8403426	No Change	$ 425.00	$ 425.00
8403427	No Change	$ 176.00	$ 176.00
8403428	No Change	$ 334.00	$ 334.00
8403429	No Change	$ 425.00	$ 425.00
8334595	No Change	$ 176.00	$ 176.00
8403424	Penalty Reduction	$ 190.00	$ 162.00
8334596	No Change	$ 150.00	$ 150.00
8334597	No Change	$ 150.00	$ 150.00
8334598	No Change	$ 150.00	$ 150.00
8334599	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 745.00	$ 350.00
8403430	No Change	$ 362.00	$ 362.00
8403431	No Change	$ 150.00	$ 150.00
8403432	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8403433	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8334600	No Change	$ 150.00	$ 150.00
8334605	No Change	$ 150.00	$ 150.00
8334606	No Change	$ 150.00	$ 150.00
8403434	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8403436	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
	Sub-Total	$14,395.00	$ 9,400.00
KENT 2010-9
8356316	Modify to 104(a) High, Unlikely, Non-S&S	$3,689.00	$3,000.00
KENT 2010-10
8356289	Penalty Reduction	$ 138.00	$ 100.00
8356290	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8356291	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 362.00	$ 300.00
8356292	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 362.00	$ 300.00
8356293	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8356294	Penalty Reduction	$ 334.00	$ 300.00
8356295	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8356296	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8356297	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8356298	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8356299	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8356816	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8356300	Penalty Reduction	$ 334.00	$ 300.00
8356301	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8356302	Penalty Reduction	$ 138.00	$ 100.00
8356303	Penalty Reduction	$ 334.00	$ 300.00
8356304	Penalty Reduction	$ 334.00	$ 300.00
8356305	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8356306	Penalty Reduction	$ 499.00	$ 400.00
8356307	Vacate	$ 100.00	$ 0.00
8356308	Penalty Reduction	$ 362.00	$ 350.00
8356309	Penalty Reduction	$ 362.00	$ 350.00
8356310	Penalty Reduction	$ 425.00	$ 400.00
8356311	Vacate	$ 100.00	$ 0.00
8356312	Vacate	$ 100.00	$ 0.00
8356313	Vacate	$ 334.00	$ 0.00
8356314	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8356315	Vacate	$2,901.00	$ 0.00
8356317	Penalty Reduction	$ 263.00	$ 200.00
8356318	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
	Sub-Total	$8,982.00	$4,900.00
KENT 2010-148
8357222	Penalty Reduction	$ 499.00	$ 400.00
8357223	Penalty Reduction	$ 285.00	$ 200.00
8357224	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$1,026.00	$ 900.00
8357225	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8357229	Penalty Reduction	$ 108.00	$ 100.00
8357230	Penalty Reduction	$ 176.00	$ 100.00
8357231	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8357238	Penalty Reduction	$ 499.00	$ 400.00
8357241	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 499.00	$ 400.00
8357242	Penalty Reduction	$ 108.00	$ 100.00
8357243	Penalty Reduction	$ 108.00	$ 100.00
8357244	Penalty Reduction	$ 108.00	$ 100.00
8357245	Penalty Reduction	$ 108.00	$ 100.00
	Sub-Total	$ 3,724.00	$3,100.00
KENT 2010-152
8356319	Modify to 104(a), Unlikely, Non-S&S, Moderate Negligence	$2,000.00	$1,500.00
8356321	Modify to 104(a), Unlikely, Non-S&S, Moderate Negligence	$2,000.00	$1,500.00
	Sub-Total	$ 4,000.00	$3,000.00
KENT 2010-918
8356556	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8356557	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8356558	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8356560	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8356561	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 308.00	$ 100.00
8356562	No Change	$ 308.00	$ 308.00
8356563	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
	Sub-Total	$ 1,116.00	$ 908.00
KENT 2010-1108
8342692	Penalty Reduction	$ 460.00	$ 240.00
8342693	Penalty Reduction	$ 334.00	$ 240.00
8342694	Penalty Reduction	$ 334.00	$ 240.00
8342695	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 308.00	$ 240.00
8342697	Modify to Moderate Negligence	$ 499.00	$ 240.00
	Sub-Total	$ 1,935.00	$1,200.00
KENT 2010-1214
8356595	Penalty Reduction	$ 308.00	$ 100.00
8356596	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 308.00	$ 100.00
8356597	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 308.00	$ 100.00
8356598	No Change	$ 807.00	$ 807.00
8356599	Modify to Low Negligence	$ 308.00	$ 138.00
8342421	No Change	$ 243.00	$ 243.00
8342423	Modify to 1 Person Affected	$ 807.00	$ 460.00
8319991	Modify to Lost Workdays or Restricted Duty	$ 499.00	$ 334.00
8342424	Modify to Low Negligence	$ 308.00	$ 100.00
8342425	Modify to 1 Person Affected	$ 807.00	$ 460.00
8342426	No Change	$ 308.00	$ 308.00
8342430	Modify to Moderate Negligence	$ 362.00	$ 108.00
8342431	Modify to 1 Person Affected	$ 540.00	$ 308.00
	Sub-Total	$5,913.00	$3,566.00
KENT 2010-1362
8357998	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 499.00	$ 100.00
8365013	No Change	$1,203.00	$1,203.00
8365014	No Change	$ 540.00	$ 540.00
8365015	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$1,140.00	$ 207.00
8365016	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 403.00	$ 100.00
8365017	No Change	$1,203.00	$1,203.00
	Sub-Total	$4,988.00	$3,353.00
KENT 2010-1365
8341957	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 362.00	$ 100.00
8341958	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 460.00	$ 113.00
8341964	Penalty Reduction	$ 687.00	$ 500.00
8341965	Penalty Reduction	$ 687.00	$ 500.00
8341966	Penalty Reduction	$ 687.00	$ 500.00
8357587	No Change	$ 362.00	$ 362.00
8403782	No Change	$ 540.00	$ 540.00
8403783	No Change	$ 585.00	$ 585.00
8403800	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
	Sub-Total	$4,470.00	$3,300.00
KENT 2010-1516
8405209	No Change	$ 745.00	$ 745.00
8364417	Vacate	$2,106.00	$ 0.00
8403809	No Change	$1,203.00	$1,203.00
	Sub-Total	$ 4,054.00	$1,948.00
KENT 2010-1518
8364049	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 807.00	$ 162.00
8364050	Modify to Lost Workdays or Restricted Duty	$ 745.00	$ 460.00
8364051	Modify to 3 Persons Affected	$ 1,203.00	$ 873.00
8364052	No Change	$ 873.00	$ 873.00
8364053	No Change	$ 745.00	$ 745.00
8364054	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 1,944.00	$ 605.00
8342442	No Change	$ 308.00	$ 308.00
8342444	No Change	$ 1,026.00	$1,026.00
8342445	No Change	$ 1,203.00	$1,203.00
8342448	No Change	$ 308.00	$ 308.00
8342449	No Change	$ 334.00	$ 334.00
8364416	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 1,795.00	$ 362.00
8342450	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 460.00	$ 100.00
8342451	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 460.00	$ 100.00
9866050	No Change	$ 499.00	$ 499.00
8364436	No Change	$ 308.00	$ 308.00
8365400	No Change	$ 243.00	$ 243.00
	Sub-Total	$13,261.00	$8,509.00
KENT 2010-1648
8357160	No Change	$ 308.00	$ 308.00
8357161	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 585.00	$ 258.00
8357164	No Change	$ 334.00	$ 334.00
	Sub-Total	$1,227.00	$ 900.00
KENT 2010-1650
8338489	Penalty Reduction	$ 190.00	$ 100.00
8338490	Penalty Reduction	$2,106.00	$1,600.00
8338491	Penalty Reduction	$ 392.00	$ 200.00
	Sub-Total	$2,688.00	$1,900.00
KENT 2011-143
8402886	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 308.00	$ 100.00
8402887	No Change	$ 263.00	$ 263.00
	Sub-Total	$ 571.00	$ 363.00
KENT 2011-144
8364090	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 362.00	$ 100.00
KENT 2011-145
8364094	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 362.00	$ 267.00
8364096	Modify to 1 Affected, Lost Workdays or Restricted Duty	$ 540.00	$ 267.00
8364098	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 362.00	$ 267.00
8364099	Modify to Lost Workdays or Restricted Duty	$ 362.00	$ 267.00
8364100	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 362.00	$ 267.00
8364101	Modify to 1 Affected, Lost Workdays or Restricted Duty	$ 540.00	$ 265.00
	Sub-Total	$2,528.00	$1,600.00
KENT 2011-156
8364462	Penalty Reduction	$ 392.00	$ 308.00
8364463	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8364465	No Change	$ 392.00	$ 392.00
8364466	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 392.00	$ 100.00
	Sub-Total	$1,276.00	$ 900.00
KENT 2011-446
8405261	Penalty Reduction	$1,203.00	$ 687.00
7502302	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
7502303	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
	Sub-Total	$1,403.00	$ 887.00
KENT 2011-447
8362842	Penalty Reduction	$ 190.00	$ 100.00
8362850	Modify to Low Negligence	$ 555.00	$ 400.00
8362854	Penalty Reduction	$ 540.00	$ 400.00
8362856	Penalty Reduction	$ 499.00	$ 300.00
8362859	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 499.00	$ 300.00
8362860	Modify to Unlikely, Non S&S	$1,026.00	$ 500.00
8362862	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 540.00	$ 400.00
8362863	Penalty Reduction	$ 499.00	$ 400.00
8362865	Modify to Low Negligence	$ 176.00	$ 100.00
8362866	Penalty Reduction	$ 873.00	$ 700.00
8362869	Penalty Reduction	$ 745.00	$ 700.00
8362870	Penalty Reduction	$ 873.00	$ 700.00
	Sub-Total	$7,015.00	$5,000.00
KENT 2011-448
8364834	Modify to Low Negligence	$ 243.00	$ 200.00
9866095	Modify to 2 Affected and Lost Work Days or Restricted Duty	$ 634.00	$ 400.00
8342535	Penalty Reduction	$ 243.00	$ 200.00
	Sub-Total	$1,120.00	$ 800.00
KENT 2011-563
8362875	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8404247	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8404248	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
	Sub-Total	$ 300.00	$ 300.00
KENT 2011-564
8342539	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 263.00	$ 100.00
8342540	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
9866114	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8342545	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
	Sub-Total	$ 563.00	$ 400.00
KENT 2011-952
8365264	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 362.00	$ 100.00
8365267	Modify to Unlikely, Non-S&S	$ 585.00	$ 117.00
9866162	No Change	$ 108.00	$ 108.00
	Sub-Total	$ 1,055.00	$ 325.00
KENT 2011-1128
8365303	Penalty Reduction	$ 263.00	$ 100.00
KENT 2009-240
8333875	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,140.00	$ 798.00
8333876	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,140.00	$ 798.00
8333878	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,140.00	$ 798.00
8333880	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,026.00	$ 718.00
8333882	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,026.00	$ 718.00
8333883	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,026.00	$ 718.00
8333901	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,026.00	$ 718.00
8333904	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,140.00	$ 798.00
8333905	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,569.00	$ 1,098.00
8333907	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,569.00	$ 1,098.00
8333908	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,140.00	$ 798.00
8333910	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,140.00	$ 798.00
8333911	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,944.00	$ 1,361.00
8333912	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,026.00	$ 718.00
8325401	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,026.00	$ 718.00
8325402	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,026.00	$ 718.00
	Sub-Total	$ 19,104.00	$ 13,371.00
KENT 2009-562
8319150	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,412.00	$ 988.00
8319151	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,944.00	$ 1,361.00
	Sub-Total	$ 3,356.00	$ 2,349.00
KENT 2010-1024
8357534	Penalty Reduction	$ 687.00	$ 481.00
8357535	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,026.00	$ 718.00
8357536	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,026.00	$ 718.00
8357538	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,026.00	$ 718.00
	Sub-Total	$ 3,765.00	$ 2,635.00
KENT 2010-1436
8341959	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,026.00	$ 718.00
8341960	Penalty Reduction	$ 2,536.00	$ 1,775.00
8341962	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,026.00	$ 718.00
8341963	Penalty Reduction	$ 2,282.00	$ 1,597.00
	Sub-Total	$ 6,870.00	$ 4,808.00
KENT 2011-991
8353025	Penalty Reduction	$ 946.00	$ 662.00
KENT 2011-992
8363307	Penalty Reduction	$ 634.00	$ 444.00
8363308	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,026.00	$ 718.00
	Sub-Total	$ 1,660.00	$ 1,162.00
KENT 2011-1053
8353261	Penalty Reduction	$ 2,678.00	$ 1,875.00
KENT 2011-1151
8353289	Penalty Reduction	$ 873.00	$ 611.00
KENT 2011-1375
8363450	Penalty Reduction	$ 4,329.00	$ 3,030.00
8363451	Penalty Reduction	$ 4,329.00	$ 3,030.00
	Sub-Total	$ 8,658.00	$ 6,060.00
KENT 2009-1549
7502506	Penalty Reduction	$ 2,901.00	$ 1,941.00
7502507	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
7502508	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
7502509	Penalty Reduction	$ 2,901.00	$ 1,971.00
7502510	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8337268	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8337269	Penalty Reduction	$ 392.00	$ 244.00
8337270	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8337271	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8337272	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8337273	Penalty Reduction	$ 392.00	$ 244.00
	Sub-Total	$ 7,286.00	$ 5,100.00
KENT 2010-767
8337873	Penalty Reduction	$ 308.00	$ 126.00
8337875	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8337876	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8337877	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8337878	Penalty Reduction	$ 585.00	$ 410.00
8337879	Penalty Reduction	$ 308.00	$ 216.00
8337880	Penalty Reduction	$ 308.00	$ 216.00
8337883	Penalty Reduction	$ 285.00	$ 200.00
8337884	Penalty Reduction	$ 285.00	$ 200.00
	Sub-Total	$ 2,379.00	$ 1,668.00
KENT 2011-795
8350457	Penalty Reduction	$ 285.00	$ 200.00
8350465	Penalty Reduction	$ 263.00	$ 124.00
8350468	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8350469	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
7502578	Penalty Reduction	$ 392.00	$ 274.00
7502579	Penalty Reduction	$ 425.00	$ 298.00
7502581	Penalty Reduction	$ 392.00	$ 274.00
	Sub-Total	$ 1,957.00	$ 1,370.00
KENT 2011-1343
8349289	Penalty Reduction	$ 176.00	$ 112.00
8349291	Penalty Reduction	$ 392.00	$ 274.00
	Sub-Total	$ 568.00	$ 386.00
KENT 2012-639
9867537	Penalty Reduction	$ 127.00	$ 100.00
KENT 2009-1601
8334659	Penalty Reduction	$ 634.00	$ 441.00
8354360	Penalty Reduction	$ 946.00	$ 710.00
8334664	Penalty Reduction	$ 634.00	$ 451.00
8354364	Penalty Reduction	$ 946.00	$ 710.00
8354365	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely	$ 1,026.00	$ 1,000.00
8334669	Penalty Reduction	$ 634.00	$ 476.00
8334670	Penalty Reduction	$ 634.00	$ 476.00
8334671	Penalty Reduction	$ 634.00	$ 476.00
8334672	Penalty Reduction	$ 127.00	$ 100.00
8403484	Penalty Reduction	$ 127.00	$ 100.00
8403483	Penalty Reduction	$ 127.00	$ 100.00
8334667	Penalty Reduction	$ 127.00	$ 100.00
8403485	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8334666	Penalty Reduction	$ 127.00	$ 100.00
8334665	Penalty Reduction	$ 127.00	$ 100.00
8334663	Penalty Reduction	$ 634.00	$ 476.00
8334661	Penalty Reduction	$ 138.00	$ 104.00
8334662	Penalty Reduction	$ 127.00	$ 100.00
8334660	Penalty Reduction	$ 308.00	$ 231.00
8319909	Penalty Reduction	$ 190.00	$ 143.00
	Sub-Total	$ 8,347.00	$ 6,494.00
KENT 2010-1211
8341934	Penalty Reduction	$38,500.00	$27,000.00
KENT 2010-1212
8341937	Penalty Reduction	$ 946.00	$ 710.00
8357969	Penalty Reduction	$ 460.00	$ 345.00
8341941	Penalty Reduction	$ 362.00	$ 272.00
8357970	Penalty Reduction	$ 460.00	$ 345.00
8357971	Penalty Reduction	$ 460.00	$ 345.00
8402839	Penalty Reduction	$ 946.00	$ 710.00
8357972	Penalty Reduction	$ 460.00	$ 345.00
8402840	Penalty Reduction	$ 460.00	$ 345.00
8402841	Penalty Reduction	$ 460.00	$ 345.00
8402842	Penalty Reduction	$ 460.00	$ 345.00
8402853	Penalty Reduction	$ 807.00	$ 605.00
8341946	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely, and 1 Affected	$ 1,795.00	$ 900.00
8402843	Penalty Reduction	$ 946.00	$ 710.00
8402846	Penalty Reduction	$ 460.00	$ 345.00
8357974	Penalty Reduction	$ 460.00	$ 345.00
8341948	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely, and 1 Affected	$ 1,530.00	$ 800.00
8341953	Penalty Reduction	$ 362.00	$ 272.00
	Sub-Total	$11,834.00	$ 8,084.00
KENT 2010-1364
8341930	Modify to 104(a) High Negligence	$27,900.00	$15,000.00
8341944	No Change	$13,600.00	$13,600.00
	Sub-Total	$41,500.00	$28,600.00
KENT 2010-1514
8365019	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,203.00	$ 1,000.00
8365020	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,203.00	$ 1,000.00
8365039	Penalty Reduction	$ 362.00	$ 272.00
8365042	Penalty Reduction	$ 362.00	$ 272.00
8365026	Penalty Reduction	$ 745.00	$ 559.00
8365027	Penalty Reduction	$ 362.00	$ 272.00
8365028	Penalty Reduction	$ 362.00	$ 272.00
8320902	Penalty Reduction	$ 308.00	$ 231.00
8364415	Penalty Reduction	$ 807.00	$ 605.00
8357156	Penalty Reduction	$ 585.00	$ 439.00
	Sub-Total	$ 6,299.00	$ 4,922.00
KENT 2010-1649
8341945	Modify to 104(a) Moderate Negligence, and 3 Affected	$15,900.00	$12,700.00
KENT 2011-154
8341942	Penalty Reduction	$38,500.00	$34,250.00
8357973	Penalty Reduction	$38,500.00	$34,250.00
8357976	Vacate	$30,200.00	$ 0.00
	Sub-Total	$107,200.00	$68,500.00
KENT 2011-347
8362587	Penalty Reduction	$ 499.00	$ 374.00
8362588	Penalty Reduction	$ 499.00	$ 374.00
8362589	Penalty Reduction	$ 499.00	$ 374.00
8362590	Penalty Reduction	$ 499.00	$ 374.00
8363001	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely	$ 1,795.00	$ 1,000.00
8363002	Penalty Reduction	$ 499.00	$ 374.00
8363003	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely	$ 1,795.00	$ 1,000.00
8362654	Penalty Reduction	$ 473.00	$ 355.00
8362655	Penalty Reduction	$ 473.00	$ 355.00
8362656	Penalty Reduction	$ 473.00	$ 355.00
8362657	Penalty Reduction	$ 540.00	$ 405.00
8362658	Penalty Reduction	$ 634.00	$ 476.00
8362659	Penalty Reduction	$ 634.00	$ 476.00
8362660	Penalty Reduction	$ 634.00	$ 476.00
8362661	Penalty Reduction	$ 634.00	$ 476.00
8362671	Penalty Reduction	$ 317.00	$ 238.00
	Sub-Total	$10,897.00	$ 7,482.00
KENT 2011-348
8365032	Modify to Lost Workdays	$ 2,000.00	$ 1,203.00
KENT 2011-350
8362832	Penalty Reduction	$ 634.00	$ 476.00
8362834	Penalty Reduction	$ 499.00	$ 374.00
8362838	Penalty Reduction	$ 634.00	$ 476.00
8362840	Penalty Reduction	$ 634.00	$ 476.00
	Sub-Total	$ 2,401.00	$ 1,802.00
KENT 2011-559
8356960	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,800.00	$ 1,500.00
8365029	Penalty Reduction	$ 8,209.00	$ 7,000.00
8365030	Penalty Reduction	$ 9,122.00	$ 7,700.00
8365031	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely	$ 7,774.00	$ 5,000.00
	Sub-Total	$26,905.00	$21,200.00
KENT 2011-560
8364862	Penalty Reduction	$ 190.00	$ 124.00
8364863	Penalty Reduction	$ 108.00	$ 100.00
8364864	Penalty Reduction	$ 540.00	$ 405.00
8364865	Penalty Reduction	$ 540.00	$ 405.00
8364866	Penalty Reduction	$ 540.00	$ 405.00
	Sub-Total	$ 1,918.00	$ 1,439.00
KENT 2011-562
8364163	Modify to 2 Affected	$ 2,678.00	$ 1,500.00
8364164	Modify to 2 Affected	$ 2,678.00	$ 1,500.00
8364165	No Change	$ 2,678.00	$ 2,678.00
8364166	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely	$ 2,678.00	$ 600.00
8364167	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely	$ 2,678.00	$ 600.00
8364168	No Change	$ 8,893.00	$ 8,893.00
8364169	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely	$ 1,530.00	$ 600.00
8364170	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely	$ 8,893.00	$ 600.00
8364171	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely	$ 5,961.00	$ 600.00
8364172	No Change	$ 8,893.00	$ 8,893.00
8364173	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely	$ 1,412.00	$ 736.00
8364174	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely	$ 2,106.00	$ 800.00
8364175	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8364176	Penalty Reduction	$ 687.00	$ 440.00
8364177	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8364178	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
	Sub-Total	$52,065.00	$28,740.00
KENT 2011-680
8335623	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8335625	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8335626	Modify to Moderate Negligence	$ 4,689.00	$ 2,450.00
	Sub-Total	$ 4,889.00	$ 2,650.00
KENT 2011-682
8364179	Modify to Reasonably Likely, 2 Affected, and Low Negligence	$13,268.00	$12,000.00
8335622	Penalty Reduction	$ 807.00	$ 605.00
8402951	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8402952	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8402953	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8402954	Penalty Reduction	$ 687.00	$ 415.00
8402955	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8364881	Penalty Reduction	$ 807.00	$ 605.00
8364882	Penalty Reduction	$ 807.00	$ 605.00
8364883	Penalty Reduction	$ 807.00	$ 605.00
8364884	Penalty Reduction	$ 362.00	$ 272.00
8364187	Penalty Reduction	$ 807.00	$ 605.00
8364188	Penalty Reduction	$ 2,678.00	$ 2,500.00
8364189	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely	$ 1,795.00	$ 1,500.00
8364190	Modify to 1 Affected	$ 1,657.00	$ 1,500.00
8364191	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely	$ 1,795.00	$ 1,500.00
8364192	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely	$ 3,689.00	$ 3,000.00
8364193	Penalty Reduction	$ 540.00	$ 405.00
8364195	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely	$ 2,678.00	$ 1,500.00
8364197	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely	$ 1,203.00	$ 1,000.00
8353004	Penalty Reduction	$ 263.00	$ 197.00
8346970	Penalty Reduction	$ 243.00	$ 182.00
8347841	Penalty Reduction	$ 745.00	$ 559.00
8406120	Penalty Reduction	$ 150.00	$ 113.00
8346971	Penalty Reduction	$ 946.00	$ 710.00
8364198	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,304.00	$ 1,000.00
8364199	Penalty Reduction	$ 2,106.00	$ 2,000.00
8353000	Penalty Reduction	$ 3,689.00	$ 3,000.00
8406123	Penalty Reduction	$ 745.00	$ 559.00
8353001	Penalty Reduction	$ 499.00	$ 374.00
8347843	Penalty Reduction	$ 263.00	$ 197.00
8406124	Penalty Reduction	$ 150.00	$ 113.00
8347844	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,657.00	$ 1,500.00
8347846	Penalty Reduction	$ 2,473.00	$ 2,000.00
8346972	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,111.00	$ 1,000.00
8406125	Penalty Reduction	$ 745.00	$ 559.00
8406126	Penalty Reduction	$ 745.00	$ 559.00
8353002	Penalty Reduction	$ 150.00	$ 113.00
8353003	Penalty Reduction	$ 150.00	$ 113.00
8406127	Penalty Reduction	$ 224.00	$ 168.00
8346973	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely	$ 1,657.00	$ 1,000.00
8406128	Penalty Reduction	$ 150.00	$ 113.00
8347847	Penalty Reduction	$ 745.00	$ 559.00
	Sub-Total	$55,697.00	$45,705.00
KENT 2011-683
8362886	Penalty Reduction	$ 745.00	$ 559.00
8362887	Penalty Reduction	$ 117.00	$ 100.00
8362888	Penalty Reduction	$ 117.00	$ 100.00
8362890	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8362891	Penalty Reduction	$ 117.00	$ 100.00
8362892	Penalty Reduction	$ 117.00	$ 100.00
8362893	Penalty Reduction	$ 150.00	$ 113.00
8403193	Penalty Reduction	$ 687.00	$ 515.00
8350237	Penalty Reduction	$ 334.00	$ 251.00
8363236	Penalty Reduction	$ 138.00	$ 104.00
8403194	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely	$ 1,530.00	$ 800.00
8403195	No Change	$ 1,203.00	$ 1,203.00
8396008	Penalty Reduction	$ 138.00	$ 104.00
8363237	Penalty Reduction	$ 138.00	$ 104.00
8396009	Penalty Reduction	$ 138.00	$ 104.00
8362894	Penalty Reduction	$ 687.00	$ 515.00
8396010	Penalty Reduction	$ 460.00	$ 345.00
8363238	Penalty Reduction	$ 138.00	$ 104.00
8403196	Penalty Reduction	$ 1,203.00	$ 900.00
8353221	Penalty Reduction	$ 687.00	$ 515.00
8363239	Penalty Reduction	$ 150.00	$ 113.00
8353222	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely, and 1 Affected	$ 3,996.00	$ 2,000.00
8363240	Penalty Reduction	$ 745.00	$ 559.00
8363241	Penalty Reduction	$ 745.00	$ 559.00
8350238	Penalty Reduction	$ 263.00	$ 197.00
8396011	Penalty Reduction	$ 243.00	$ 182.00
8363242	Penalty Reduction	$ 334.00	$ 251.00
8362898	Penalty Reduction	$ 176.00	$ 132.00
8362899	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8363301	Penalty Reduction	$ 585.00	$ 341.00
	Sub-Total	$16,281.00	$11,170.00
KENT 2011-684
8342378	Penalty Reduction	$ 138.00	$ 104.00
8342379	Penalty Reduction	$ 207.00	$ 155.00
8342548	Penalty Reduction	$ 425.00	$ 203.00
8342550	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8342549	Penalty Reduction	$ 243.00	$ 182.00
8342551	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8342552	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8342553	Penalty Reduction	$ 243.00	$ 182.00
8342554	Penalty Reduction	$ 112.00	$ 100.00
8342555	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
	Sub-Total	$ 1,768.00	$ 1,326.00
KENT 2011-817
8365251	Penalty Reduction	$ 540.00	$ 405.00
8406405	Penalty Reduction	$ 243.00	$ 182.00
8353230	Penalty Reduction	$ 190.00	$ 143.00
8406407	Penalty Reduction	$ 190.00	$ 143.00
8406408	Penalty Reduction	$ 190.00	$ 143.00
8353231	Penalty Reduction	$ 190.00	$ 143.00
8365252	Penalty Reduction	$ 190.00	$ 143.00
	Sub-Total	$ 1,733.00	$ 1,302.00
KENT 2011-823
8353007	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely	$ 3,143.00	$ 1,700.00
8353008	Modify to 1 Affected	$ 3,143.00	$ 2,645.00
8353009	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely	$ 3,143.00	$ 1,700.00
8353010	Penalty Reduction	$ 946.00	$ 710.00
8353011	Penalty Reduction	$ 946.00	$ 710.00
8353012	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely	$ 3,143.00	$ 1,700.00
8353013	No Change	$ 1,203.00	$ 1,203.00
8353016	No Change	$ 1,052.00	$ 1,052.00
	Sub-Total	$16,719.00	$11,420.00
KENT 2011-824
8363302	Penalty Reduction	$ 687.00	$ 515.00
8363304	Penalty Reduction	$ 138.00	$ 104.00
8363306	Penalty Reduction	$ 745.00	$ 559.00
8405815	Penalty Reduction	$ 687.00	$ 515.00
	Sub-Total	$ 2,257.00	$ 1,693.00
KENT 2011-947
8364682	No Change	$ 1,235.00	$ 1,235.00
8364683	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely	$ 1,026.00	$ 1,026.00
8353251	No Change	$ 1,026.00	$ 1,026.00
8353252	Penalty Reduction	$ 207.00	$ 155.00
8353253	Modify to Reasonably Likely, Lost Workdays, 1 Affected	$ 9,634.00	$ 3,639.00
8353254	No Change	$ 1,026.00	$ 1,026.00
8353255	Penalty Reduction	$ 207.00	$ 155.00
8353257	No Change	$ 1,026.00	$ 1,026.00
8353258	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely	$ 3,996.00	$ 2,000.00
8353259	No Change	$ 1,026.00	$ 1,026.00
8353260	No Change	$ 3,996.00	$ 3,996.00
	Sub-Total	$24,405.00	$16,310.00
KENT 2011-948
8364541	No Change	$ 1,111.00	$ 1,111.00
8364544	Vacate	$ 1,111.00	$ 0.00
	Sub-Total	$ 2,222.00	$ 1,111.00
KENT 2011-949
8342494	Modify to 1 Affected	$ 3,200.00	$ 1,600.00
KENT 2011-950
8353033	Penalty Reduction	$ 946.00	$ 705.00
8353034	Penalty Reduction	$ 634.00	$ 476.00
8353035	Penalty Reduction	$ 634.00	$ 476.00
8353036	Penalty Reduction	$ 634.00	$ 476.00
8365265	Vacate	$ 1,111.00	$ 0.00
8365266	No Change	$ 1,795.00	$ 1,795.00
8353042	Penalty Reduction	$ 127.00	$ 100.00
	Sub-Total	$ 5,881.00	$ 4,028.00
KENT 2011-951
8353235	Penalty Reduction	$ 138.00	$ 104.00
8363330	Penalty Reduction	$ 392.00	$ 294.00
8364542	Vacate	$ 1,203.00	$ 0.00
8364543	Penalty Reduction	$ 2,678.00	$ 1,795.00
	Sub-Total	$ 4,411.00	$ 2,193.00
KENT 2011-1129
8404158	Penalty Reduction	$ 127.00	$ 100.00
8365301	Penalty Reduction	$ 807.00	$ 600.00
8365302	Penalty Reduction	$ 634.00	$ 441.00
8365304	Penalty Reduction	$ 127.00	$ 100.00
8365305	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8365306	Penalty Reduction	$ 127.00	$ 100.00
8365307	Penalty Reduction	$ 634.00	$ 471.00
8365308	Penalty Reduction	$ 127.00	$ 100.00
8365309	Penalty Reduction	$ 634.00	$ 476.00
8365310	Penalty Reduction	$ 634.00	$ 476.00
8353080	Penalty Reduction	$ 263.00	$ 197.00
	Sub-Total	$ 4,214.00	$ 3,161.00
KENT 2011-1130
8364923	Penalty Reduction	$ 207.00	$ 130.00
8405330	No Change	$ 100.00	$ 100.00
8405332	Penalty Reduction	$ 540.00	$ 405.00
8405333	Penalty Reduction	$ 334.00	$ 251.00
8405334	Penalty Reduction	$ 362.00	$ 272.00
8405336	Penalty Reduction	$ 308.00	$ 231.00
	Sub-Total	$ 1,851.00	$ 1,389.00

KENT 2011-1133
8363409		Penalty Reduction		$ 745.00		$ 509.00
8363410		Penalty Reduction		$ 224.00		$ 168.00
8363411		Penalty Reduction		$ 224.00		$ 168.00
8363412		Penalty Reduction		$ 224.00		$ 168.00
8363413		Penalty Reduction		$ 687.00		$ 515.00
8363414		Penalty Reduction		$ 243.00		$ 182.00
8363416		Penalty Reduction		$ 687.00		$ 515.00
8363417		Penalty Reduction		$ 687.00		$ 515.00
8363418		Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,412.00		$ 800.00
8363419		Penalty Reduction		$ 2,678.00		$ 2,000.00
8363420		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8363421		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
		Sub-Total		$ 8,011.00		$ 5,740.00
KENT 2011-1234
8365361		Penalty Reduction		$ 127.00		$ 100.00
8365362		Penalty Reduction		$ 162.00		$ 112.00
8365364		Penalty Reduction		$ 243.00		$ 182.00
8353861		Penalty Reduction		$ 138.00		$ 104.00
8406252		Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,304.00		$ 500.00
8353862		Penalty Reduction		$ 138.00		$ 104.00
8353863		Penalty Reduction		$ 634.00		$ 476.00
8406253		Penalty Reduction		$ 634.00		$ 476.00
8365365		Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,111.00		$ 700.00
8406254		Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,111.00		$ 700.00
8406255		Penalty Reduction		$ 634.00		$ 476.00
8353864		Penalty Reduction		$ 634.00		$ 476.00
8406256		Penalty Reduction		$ 190.00		$ 143.00
8406257		Penalty Reduction		$ 634.00		$ 476.00
8406258		No Change		$ 1,111.00		$ 1,111.00
8365367		Penalty Reduction		$ 127.00		$ 100.00
		Sub-Total		$ 8,932.00		$ 6,236.00
KENT 2011-1235
8335669		Penalty Reduction		$ 207.00		$ 155.00
KENT 2011-1236
8352988		Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,026.00		$ 300.00
8352991		Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,026.00		$ 300.00
8352992		Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,026.00		$ 300.00
8352993		Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,026.00		$ 300.00
8352994		Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,026.00		$ 300.00
8352995		Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,026.00		$ 300.00
8352996		No Change		$ 1,026.00		$ 1,026.00
8352997		Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,026.00		$ 300.00
8352998		Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,026.00		$ 300.00
8352999		Penalty Reduction		$ 207.00		$ 155.00
8363701		No Change		$ 1,026.00		$ 1,026.00
8363702		Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,026.00		$ 300.00
8363703		No Change		$ 1,026.00		$ 1,026.00
8363704		Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,140.00		$ 300.00
8363705		No Change		$ 1,026.00		$ 1,026.00
8363706		No Change		$ 1,026.00		$ 1,026.00
8363708		Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,026.00		$ 300.00
8363711		No Change		$ 1,026.00		$ 1,026.00
8363712		Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,026.00		$ 300.00
		Sub-Total		$18,789.00		$ 9,911.00
KENT 2011-1332
8363714		Penalty Reduction		$ 807.00		$ 605.00
8363715		Penalty Reduction		$ 807.00		$ 605.00
8363716		Penalty Reduction		$ 807.00		$ 605.00
8363717		Penalty Reduction		$ 807.00		$ 605.00
8363718		Penalty Reduction		$ 1,412.00		$ 1,200.00
8363719		Penalty Reduction		$ 807.00		$ 605.00
8363720		Penalty Reduction		$ 807.00		$ 605.00
8406815		Penalty Reduction		$ 162.00		$ 122.00
8363723		Penalty Reduction		$ 807.00		$ 605.00
8406816		Penalty Reduction		$ 162.00		$ 122.00
8363724		Penalty Reduction		$ 807.00		$ 605.00
8363725		Penalty Reduction		$ 807.00		$ 605.00
8406817		Penalty Reduction		$ 807.00		$ 510.00
8406818		Penalty Reduction		$ 162.00		$ 122.00
8406819		Penalty Reduction		$ 162.00		$ 122.00
		Sub-Total		$10,130.00		$ 7,643.00
KENT 2011-1333
7496996		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
7496997		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
7496998		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8364993		Penalty Reduction		$ 207.00		$ 155.00
8364995		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8364998		Penalty Reduction		$ 425.00		$ 219.00
8368001		Penalty Reduction		$ 425.00		$ 319.00
8368002		Penalty Reduction		$ 460.00		$ 345.00
8368003		Penalty Reduction		$ 460.00		$ 345.00
8368005		Penalty Reduction		$ 460.00		$ 315.00
		Sub-Total		$ 2,837.00		$ 2,098.00
KENT 2011-1335
8365369		Penalty Reduction		$ 127.00		$ 100.00
8335671		Penalty Reduction		$ 946.00		$ 705.00
		Sub-Total		$ 1,073.00		$ 805.00
KENT 2011-1336
8362833		Modify to Non S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,700.00		$ 800.00
KENT 2011-1342
8335670		Penalty Reduction		$ 207.00		$ 155.00
KENT 2011-1493
8406830		Penalty Reduction		$ 127.00		$ 100.00
8406831		Penalty Reduction		$ 127.00		$ 100.00
8406832		Penalty Reduction		$ 127.00		$ 100.00
8406833		Penalty Reduction		$ 127.00		$ 100.00
8406838		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8406839		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8406840		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
		Sub-Total		$ 808.00		$ 700.00
KENT 2011-1494
8368013		Penalty Reduction		$ 127.00		$ 100.00
8368014		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
		Sub-Total		$ 227.00		$ 200.00
KENT 2011-1496
8365393		Modify to Non S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,412.00		$ 900.00
8365395		Penalty Reduction		$ 946.00		$ 710.00
8365396		Penalty Reduction		$ 585.00		$ 439.00
8365397		Penalty Reduction		$ 150.00		$ 113.00
		Sub-Total		$ 3,093.00		$ 2,162.00
KENT 2012-21
8347845		Penalty Reduction		$ 1,944.00		$ 1,500.00
8365398		Penalty Reduction		$ 745.00		$ 559.00
8365399		Penalty Reduction		$ 150.00		$ 113.00
8368200		Penalty Reduction		$ 745.00		$ 559.00
8368201		Penalty Reduction		$ 162.00		$ 122.00
8368202		Penalty Reduction		$ 745.00		$ 559.00
8368203		Penalty Reduction		$ 807.00		$ 605.00
8368205		Modify to Non S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,412.00		$ 800.00
8363957		Penalty Reduction		$ 150.00		$ 113.00
8363958		Penalty Reduction		$ 499.00		$ 374.00
8363959		No Change		$ 2,473.00		$ 2,473.00
8368048		Penalty Reduction		$ 150.00		$ 113.00
8363960		Penalty Reduction		$ 150.00		$ 113.00
8363961		Modify to 1 Person Affected		$ 2,473.00		$ 2,200.00
8368215		Modify to Non S&S, Unlikely, 1 Person Affected		$ 4,329.00		$ 1,500.00
8368214		Modify to Non S&S, Unlikely, 1 Person Affected		$ 4,329.00		$ 1,500.00
8363962		Penalty Reduction		$ 150.00		$ 113.00
8368049		Penalty Reduction		$ 1,111.00		$ 800.00
8368050		Modify to Non S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,657.00		$ 1,200.00
8368053		Penalty Reduction		$ 150.00		$ 113.00
8368221		Penalty Reduction		$ 807.00		$ 605.00
8368222		Penalty Reduction		$ 807.00		$ 605.00
		Sub-Total		$25,945.00		$ 16,639.00
KENT 2012-24
8405380		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8405385		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8405386		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8365675		Penalty Reduction		$ 334.00		$ 151.00
8365674		Penalty Reduction		$ 207.00		$ 155.00
8365676		Penalty Reduction		$ 334.00		$ 251.00
8365677		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
		Sub-Total		$ 1,275.00		$ 957.00
KENT 2012-137
8353573		Penalty Reduction		$ 873.00		$ 555.00
KENT 2012-138
8368105		Penalty Reduction		$ 207.00		$ 105.00
8368106		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8368107		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8368108		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8368109		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8368110		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8368111		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
		Sub-Total		$ 807.00		$ 705.00
KENT 2012-139
8368212		Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely, and Moderate Negligence		$ 3,689.00		$ 1,500.00
8404157		No Change		$ 3,143.00		$ 3,143.00
		Sub-Total		$ 6,832.00		$ 4,643.00
KENT 2012-140
8364438		Penalty Reduction		$ 1,000.00		$ 600.00
8362855		Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,800.00		$ 1,600.00
8362885		Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 2,400.00		$ 1,600.00
		Sub-Total		$ 5,200.00		$ 3,800.00
KENT 2012-141
8363415		Modify to 2 Affected		$ 2,901.00		$ 1,700.00
8406495		Penalty Reduction		$ 117.00		$ 100.00
8406272		Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,944.00		$ 1,250.00
8406273		Penalty Reduction		$ 651.00		$ 476.00
		Sub-Total		$ 5,613.00		$ 3,526.00
KENT 2012-142
8405331		Penalty Reduction		$ 540.00		$ 405.00
8405335		Penalty Reduction		$ 460.00		$ 345.00
		Sub-Total		$ 1,000.00		$ 750.00
KENT 2012-320
8352990		Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 4,329.00		$ 1,000.00
KENT 2012-321
8368636		Penalty Reduction		$ 946.00		$ 710.00
8365368		Modify to Reasonably Likely and Moderate Negligence		$ 23,229.00		$15,000.00
8365363		Penalty Reduction		$ 634.00		$ 476.00
8365366		Penalty Reduction		$ 634.00		$ 476.00
8405748		Modify to 1 Affected		$ 4,689.00		$ 4,000.00
8405749		No Change		$ 1,657.00		$ 1,657.00
		Sub-Total		$31,789.00		$22,319.00
KENT 2012-322
8363431		Modify to Moderate Negligence		$ 5,080.00		$ 3,250.00
8406477		Modify to 1 Affected, and Moderate Negligence		$11,306.00		$ 8,000.00
8406478		Penalty Reduction		$ 1,944.00		$ 1,575.00
8363678		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
		Sub-Total		$18,430.00		$12,925.00
KENT 2012-323
8368622		Penalty Reduction		$ 207.00		$ 139.00
8368625		Penalty Reduction		$ 112.00		$ 100.00
8368637		Penalty Reduction		$ 207.00		$ 130.00
		Sub-Total		$ 526.00		$ 369.00
KENT 2012-413
8364985		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8363880		Penalty Reduction		$ 207.00		$ 130.00
8363881		Penalty Reduction		$ 207.00		$ 155.00
		Sub-Total		$ 514.00		$ 385.00
KENT 2012-415
8362889		Penalty Reduction		$ 1,400.00		$ 900.00
8363300		Penalty Reduction		$ 2,700.00		$ 1,500.00
8363430		Penalty Reduction		$ 2,500.00		$ 1,800.00
		Sub-Total		$ 6,600.00		$ 4,200.00
KENT 2012-416
8363454		Penalty Reduction		$ 873.00		$ 530.00
8363872		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8363873		Penalty Reduction		$ 499.00		$ 374.00
8363874		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8363875		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8363876		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8363877		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
		Sub-Total		$ 1,872.00		$ 1,404.00
KENT 2012-723
8402059		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
KENT 2012-724
8404175		Penalty Reduction		$ 176.00		$ 132.00
8404176		Penalty Reduction		$ 263.00		$ 172.00
		Sub-Total		$ 439.00		$ 304.00
KENT 2012-729
8353163		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
KENT 2012-839
8368685		Penalty Reduction		$ 243.00		$ 157.00
KENT 2012-840
8363891		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8363890		Penalty Reduction		$ 150.00		$ 113.00
		Sub-Total		$ 250.00		$ 213.00
KENT 2012-842
8363887		Penalty Reduction		$ 263.00		$ 197.00
8363894		Penalty Reduction		$ 263.00		$ 172.00
8363895		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
		Sub-Total		$ 626.00		$ 469.00
KENT 2012-845
8368677		No Change		$ 1,657.00		$ 1,400.00
KENT 2012-847
8368247		Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 5,503.00		$ 2,000.00
8368671		Penalty Reduction		$ 1,944.00		$ 1,500.00
8368674		Penalty Reduction		$ 499.00		$ 374.00
8368675		Penalty Reduction		$ 224.00		$ 168.00
8368678		Penalty Reduction		$ 8,209.00		$ 6,000.00
8368679		Penalty Reduction		$ 425.00		$ 319.00
8368680		Penalty Reduction		$ 425.00		$ 319.00
8368681		Penalty Reduction		$ 334.00		$ 251.00
		Sub-Total		$17,563.00		$10,931.00
KENT 2012-848
8365678		Modify to 104(a), Moderate Negligence		$11,000.00		$ 5,500.00
8365679		Penalty Reduction		$17,800.00		$14,000.00
8365680		Penalty Reduction		$24,600.00		$19,000.00
		Sub-Total		$53,400.00		$38,500.00
KENT 2012-849
8368331		Penalty Reduction		$ 150.00		$ 113.00
KENT 2012-974
8378200		Penalty Reduction		$ 150.00		$ 113.00
8378201		Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,111.00		$ 500.00
8378202		Vacate		$ 1,111.00		$ 0.00
8378203		Penalty Reduction		$ 585.00		$ 439.00
8378205		Penalty Reduction		$ 873.00		$ 655.00
8378206		Penalty Reduction		$ 243.00		$ 182.00
8378207		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8378208		Penalty Reduction		$ 585.00		$ 439.00
8378210		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8378211		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8378212		Penalty Reduction		$ 745.00		$ 559.00
8378213		Penalty Reduction		$ 807.00		$ 605.00
8378214		Penalty Reduction		$ 150.00		$ 113.00
8402779		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8402780		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8402781		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8402782		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8402783		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8402784		Penalty Reduction		$ 150.00		$ 113.00
8402785		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8402786		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8378216		Penalty Reduction		$ 745.00		$ 259.00
8378217		Penalty Reduction		$ 150.00		$ 113.00
8378218		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8378219		Penalty Reduction		$ 150.00		$ 113.00
8378220		Penalty Reduction		$ 150.00		$ 113.00
8378222		Penalty Reduction		$ 150.00		$ 113.00
8378223		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
		Sub-Total		$ 9,055.00		$ 5,629.00
KENT 2011-1497
8363456		Penalty Reduction		$ 2,282.00		$ 1,800.00
8363457		Penalty Reduction		$ 2,282.00		$ 1,800.00
		Sub-Total		$ 4,564.00		$ 3,600.00
KENT 2012-22
8406482		Penalty Reduction		$ 585.00		$ 357.00
8406483		Penalty Reduction		$ 176.00		$ 132.00
8406489		Penalty Reduction		$ 585.00		$ 439.00
8363473		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8353911		Modify to 2 Affected		$ 4,440.00		$ 2,250.00
8406468		Penalty Reduction		$ 651.00		$ 488.00
8406469		Penalty Reduction		$ 651.00		$ 488.00
8406470		Penalty Reduction		$ 131.00		$ 100.00
8406471		Penalty Reduction		$ 131.00		$ 100.00
8406472		Penalty Reduction		$ 651.00		$ 488.00
8406473		Penalty Reduction		$ 971.00		$ 728.00
8406474		Penalty Reduction		$ 131.00		$ 100.00
8406475		Penalty Reduction		$ 651.00		$ 488.00
8406476		Penalty Reduction		$ 131.00		$ 100.00
8406481		Penalty Reduction		$ 112.00		$ 100.00
8406480		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8406479		Penalty Reduction		$ 131.00		$ 100.00
8406484		Penalty Reduction		$ 403.00		$ 302.00
8406485		Penalty Reduction		$ 167.00		$ 125.00
8406486		Penalty Reduction		$ 142.00		$ 107.00
8406487		Penalty Reduction		$ 651.00		$ 488.00
8406488		Penalty Reduction		$ 131.00		$ 100.00
8406490		Penalty Reduction		$ 705.00		$ 529.00
8406491		Penalty Reduction		$ 705.00		$ 529.00
8406493		Penalty Reduction		$ 142.00		$ 107.00
8406494		Penalty Reduction		$ 705.00		$ 529.00
8406497		Penalty Reduction		$ 651.00		$ 488.00
8406498		Penalty Reduction		$ 651.00		$ 488.00
8406500		Penalty Reduction		$ 705.00		$ 529.00
8406501		Penalty Reduction		$ 131.00		$ 100.00
8406502		Penalty Reduction		$ 131.00		$ 100.00
8406503		Vacate		$ 131.00		$ 0.00
		Sub-Total		$16,479.00		$11,179.00
KENT 2012-726
8363652		Penalty Reduction		$ 1,412.00		$ 1,058.00
8368047		Penalty Reduction		$ 243.00		$ 132.00
8368451		Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,026.00		$ 500.00
8368660		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8368661		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8368452		Penalty Reduction		$ 1,026.00		$ 900.00
8368663		Penalty Reduction		$ 634.00		$ 476.00
9867539		Penalty Reduction		$ 190.00		$ 143.00
8368670		Penalty Reduction		$ 946.00		$ 710.00
9867549		Penalty Reduction		$ 392.00		$ 294.00
		Sub-Total		$ 6,069.00		$ 4,413.00
KENT 2012-728
8363455		Penalty Reduction		$ 1,530.00		$ 1,100.00
8363458		Modify to Moderate Negligence		$ 1,530.00		$ 775.00
8353919		Modify to Reasonably Likely		$ 3,784.00		$ 2,000.00
8363882		No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
		Sub-Total		$ 6,944.00		$ 3,975.00
KENT 2012-885
8406499		Penalty Reduction		$ 4,200.00		$ 2,500.00
8406496		Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 2,800.00		$ 1,500.00
		Sub-Total		$ 7,000.00		$ 4,000.00
KENT 2009-1286
8320791	No Change			$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8320792	No Change			$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8320793	No Change			$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8320794	Penalty Reduction			$ 334.00		$ 251.00
8320795	Penalty Reduction			$ 334.00		$ 201.00
8320796	Penalty Reduction			$ 224.00		$ 143.00
8356200	Penalty Reduction			$ 138.00		$ 104.00
8356201	No Change			$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8356204	No Change			$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8356205	No Change			$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8356207	No Change			$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8356208	No Change			$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8356211	Penalty Reduction			$ 687.00		$ 390.00
8356213	Penalty Reduction			$ 285.00		$ 214.00
8356214	Penalty Reduction			$ 334.00		$ 201.00
8356215	No Change			$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8338397	No Change			$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8338398	Penalty Reduction			$ 334.00		$ 251.00
8338399	Penalty Reduction			$ 1,026.00		$ 770.00
8338400	Penalty Reduction			$ 634.00		$ 426.00
8356216	No Change			$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8356217	Penalty Reduction			$ 555.00		$ 416.00
8356218	No Change			$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8356219	Penalty Reduction			$ 334.00		$ 201.00
8356220	Penalty Reduction			$ 334.00		$ 201.00
8356221	Penalty Reduction			$ 334.00		$ 251.00
8356222	Penalty Reduction			$ 1,203.00		$ 902.00
8400602	No Change			$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8356224	Penalty Reduction			$ 224.00		$ 168.00
8356225	Penalty Reduction			$ 224.00		$ 168.00
8356226	Penalty Reduction			$ 585.00		$ 439.00
8356227	Penalty Reduction			$ 334.00		$ 251.00
8356228	No Change			$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8356229	No Change			$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8356230	Penalty Reduction			$ 540.00		$ 405.00
8356231	Penalty Reduction			$ 334.00		$ 251.00
9887160	Penalty Reduction			$ 499.00		$ 374.00
8356232	No Change			$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8356234	Penalty Reduction			$ 362.00		$ 272.00
8356235	Penalty Reduction			$ 334.00		$ 251.00
8356236	Penalty Reduction			$ 334.00		$ 251.00
8356237	Penalty Reduction			$ 334.00		$ 251.00
8356238	Penalty Reduction			$ 334.00		$ 251.00
8356239	No Change			$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8356240	Penalty Reduction			$ 334.00		$ 201.00
8356241	No Change			$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8356242	Penalty Reduction			$ 334.00		$ 201.00
8356243	No Change			$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8356244	Penalty Reduction			$ 334.00		$ 251.00
8356245	No Change			$ 100.00		$ 100.00
	Sub-Total			$ 14,530.00		$ 10,907.00
KENT 2009-1388
9887162	Penalty Reduction		$ 392.00		$ 294.00
8403439	No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8403435	No Change		$ 362.00		$ 362.00
8356246	No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8403440	No Change		$ 334.00		$ 334.00
8403441	No Change		$ 334.00		$ 334.00
8403442	No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8356247	No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8356248	No Change		$ 362.00		$ 362.00
8303443	No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8356249	No Change		$ 362.00		$ 362.00
8356250	No Change		$ 334.00		$ 334.00
8356259	No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8335344	No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8335345	No Change		$ 362.00		$ 362.00
8335346	No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8403446	No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8335347	No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8403447	No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8335348	Penalty Reduction		$ 362.00		$ 272.00
8403448	No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8335351	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,795.00		$ 538.00
	Sub-Total		$ 6,199.00		$ 4,754.00
KENT 2010-1515
8341943	Modify to 104(a), Reasonably Likely and 2 Affected		$ 47,200.00		$ 25,000.00
KENT 2010-1517
8356594	Penalty Reduction		$ 2,300.00		$ 1,200.00
8364000	Modify to 104(a), Reasonably Likely		$ 53,800.00		$ 32,500.00
8364002	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 2,300.00		$ 1,500.00
	Sub-Total		$ 58,400.00		$ 35,200.00
KENT 2011-155
8402897	Penalty Reduction		$ 150.00		$ 113.00
8405235	Penalty Reduction		$ 745.00		$ 559.00
8342492	Penalty Reduction		$ 162.00		$ 122.00
8342493	Penalty Reduction		$ 162.00		$ 122.00
8342495	Penalty Reduction		$ 499.00		$ 374.00
8342496	Penalty Reduction		$ 460.00		$ 345.00
8342497	Penalty Reduction		$ 807.00		$ 605.00
9866073	Penalty Reduction		$ 540.00		$ 405.00
8402891	Penalty Reduction		$ 460.00		$ 345.00
8402892	Penalty Reduction		$ 745.00		$ 559.00
8335494	Penalty Reduction		$ 745.00		$ 559.00
8335495	Penalty Reduction		$ 745.00		$ 559.00
8342501	Penalty Reduction		$ 807.00		$ 605.00
	Sub-Total		$ 7,027.00		$ 5,272.00
KENT 2011-349
8405157	Penalty Reduction		$ 138.00		$ 104.00
8404215	Penalty Reduction		$ 362.00		$ 272.00
8405158	Penalty Reduction		$ 540.00		$ 405.00
8404218	No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8405159	Penalty Reduction		$ 362.00		$ 272.00
8405160	Penalty Reduction		$ 150.00		$ 113.00
8405161	Penalty Reduction		$ 873.00		$ 655.00
8402902	Penalty Reduction		$ 687.00		$ 515.00
8402905	Penalty Reduction		$ 540.00		$ 405.00
8342512	Penalty Reduction		$ 634.00		$ 476.00
8342515	Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 2,106.00		$ 1,100.00
8357184	Penalty Reduction		$ 392.00		$ 294.00
8342522	Penalty Reduction		$ 127.00		$ 100.00
8342523	Penalty Reduction		$ 392.00		$ 294.00
8342524	Penalty Reduction		$ 745.00		$ 559.00
8342526	Penalty Reduction		$ 540.00		$ 405.00
8364117	Penalty Reduction		$ 540.00		$ 405.00
8364118	Penalty Reduction		$ 540.00		$ 405.00
8364119	No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8364120	Penalty Reduction		$ 946.00		$ 710.00
8364121	Penalty Reduction		$ 540.00		$ 338.00
9866085	Penalty Reduction		$ 117.00		$ 100.00
	Sub-Total		$11,471.00		$ 8,127.00
KENT 2011-561
8403810	Modify to 104(a), 1 Affected		$ 9,122.00		$ 6,000.00
8403811	Modify to 104(a), Moderate Negligence		$ 4,810.00		$ 1,304.00
	Sub-Total		$13,932.00		$ 7,304.00
KENT 2011-681
8403812	Penalty Reduction		$25,800.00		$ 12,900.00
8403813	Modify to 104(a), High Negligence Citation		$19,300.00		$ 13,000.00
	Sub-Total		$45,100.00		$ 25,900.00
KENT 2011-1132
8364680	Modify to Reasonably Likely, Lost Workdays		$ 25,163.00		$ 17,000.00
8364681	Modify to Reasonably Likely. Lost Workdays		$ 25,163.00		$ 17,000.00
8353256	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,026.00		$ 550.00
8353266	Penalty Reduction		$ 207.00		$ 155.00
8353267	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,026.00		$ 800.00
8404009	Penalty Reduction		$ 207.00		$ 155.00
8353286	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 3,405.00		$ 800.00
8353287	No Change		$ 2,901.00		$ 2,901.00
8353288	Penalty Reduction		$ 425.00		$ 319.00
8353290	Penalty Reduction		$ 807.00		$ 605.00
8352977	Penalty Reduction		$ 207.00		$ 155.00
8352978	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,026.00		$ 897.00
8352979	No Change		$ 1,026.00		$ 1,026.00
8352980	No Change		$ 1,026.00		$ 1,026.00
	Sub-Total		$ 63,615.00		$ 43,389.00
KENT 2011-1237
8363422	No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8363423	Penalty Reduction		$ 138.00		$ 104.00
8363427	Penalty Reduction		$ 117.00		$ 100.00
8363428	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,203.00		$ 900.00
8363429	Penalty Reduction		$ 585.00		$ 402.00
8363432	Penalty Reduction		$ 117.00		$ 100.00
8363433	Penalty Reduction		$ 585.00		$ 413.00
8363434	Penalty Reduction		$ 117.00		$ 100.00
8363435	Penalty Reduction		$ 745.00		$ 559.00
8363436	Penalty Reduction		$ 2,282.00		$ 1,282.00
8363437	Penalty Reduction		$ 131.00		$ 100.00
8363441	Penalty Reduction		$ 585.00		$ 439.00
8363442	Penalty Reduction		$ 585.00		$ 439.00
	Sub-Total		$ 7,290.00		$ 5,038.00
KENT 2011-1334
8342516	Modify to No Lost Workdays		$ 8,600.00		$ 4,000.00
KENT 2011-1337
8406459	Penalty Reduction		$ 117.00		$ 100.00
8363443	Penalty Reduction		$ 127.00		$ 100.00
8363444	Penalty Reduction		$ 117.00		$ 100.00
8363445	Penalty Reduction		$ 585.00		$ 374.00
8363446	Penalty Reduction		$ 2,282.00		$ 1,500.00
8363447	Penalty Reduction		$ 460.00		$ 345.00
8363448	Penalty Reduction		$ 117.00		$ 100.00
8363449	Penalty Reduction		$ 117.00		$ 100.00
8363452	Penalty Reduction		$ 460.00		$ 345.00
8363453	Penalty Reduction		$ 117.00		$ 100.00
			$ 4,499.00		$ 3,164.00
KENT 2011-1495
8364181	Modify to 104(a), 2 Affected		$ 52,500.00		$ 20,000.00
8364194	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely and 1 Affected		$ 13,600.00		$ 6,800.00
	Sub-Total		$ 66,100.00		$ 26,800.00
KENT 2011-1498
8363459	Penalty Reduction		$ 263.00		$ 197.00
8363460	Modify to Moderate Negligence		$ 1,700.00		$ 750.00
8353925	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 2,536.00		$ 750.00
	Sub-Total		$ 4,499.00		$ 1,697.00
KENT 2012-20
8347842	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 4,000.00		$ 4,000.00
8406122	Modify to 1 Affected		$ 10,705.00		$ 8,000.00
	Sub-Total		$ 14,705.00		$ 12,000.00
KENT 2012-23
8342546	Modify to Reasonably Likely, Lost Workdays		$ 38,500.00		$ 25,000.00
8342557	Modify to Non-S&S, Unlikely		$ 1,800.00		$ 1,300.00
	Sub-Total		$ 40,300.00		$ 26,300.00
KENT 2012-414
8368064	Modify to Reasonably Likely		$ 70,000.00		$ 35,000.00
KENT 2012-725
8368065	Modify to 104(a), Moderate Negligence and Reasonably Likely		$ 70,000.00		$ 39,000.00
8368211	No Change		$ 14,373.00		$ 7,200.00
8368213	Modify to 104(a), Moderate Negligence, and Reasonably Likely		$ 35,543.00		$ 17,771.00
8368218	Vacate		$ 13,609.00		$ 0.00
8368054	Modify to 104(a), Moderate Negligence, and Reasonably Likely		$ 30,288.00		$ 15,144.00
8368219	Modify to High Negligence and Reasonably Likely		$ 70,000.00		$ 35,000.00
8368220	Modify to 104(a), High Negligence, and Reasonably Likely		$ 60,000.00		$ 30,000.00
	Sub-Total		$293,813.00		$144,115.00
KENT 2012-841
8406504	Modify to 104(a), Unlikely		$ 7,176.00		$ 5,000.00
8353920	Modify to 104(a), Lost Workdays		$ 56,929.00		$ 16,000.00
8353935	Modify to Lost Workdays		$ 2,000.00		$ 2,000.00
	Sub-Total		$ 66,105.00		$ 23,000.00
KENT 2012-846
8368063	Modify to 104(a), Moderate Negligence, and Reasonably Likely		$ 70,000.00		$ 35,800.00
8368051	Modify to Reasonably Likely		$ 70,000.00		$ 35,000.00
8368217	Modify to Reasonably Likely		$ 70,000.00		$ 40,000.00
	Sub-Total		$210,000.00		$110,800.00
KENT 2012-1394
8378048	Penalty Reduction		$ 575.00		$ 431.00
KENT 2012-1499
8363896	Penalty Reduction		$ 293.00		$ 170.00
8408540	No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8408541	No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
	Sub-Total		$ 493.00		$ 370.00
KENT 2012-1501
8368676	Penalty Reduction		$ 1,657.00		$ 600.00
KENT 2013-17
8378081	Penalty Reduction		$ 1,100.00		$ 500.00
KENT 2013-18
8378204	Penalty Reduction		$ 585.00		$ 439.00
8378215	Penalty Reduction		$ 224.00		$ 172.00
8378124	No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8378125	Penalty Reduction		$ 745.00		$ 459.00
	Sub-Total		$ 1,654.00		$ 1,170.00
KENT 2013-352
8369645	No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8369647	No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
8369648	No Change		$ 100.00		$ 100.00
	Sub-Total		$ 300.00		$ 300.00
KENT 2010-1213
8364001	Modify to Permanently Disabling & Moderate Negligence		$ 9,122.00		$ 6,122.00
GLOBAL SETTLEMENT TOTAL			$1,994,395.00		$1,197,365.00

WHEREFORE, the motions to approve settlement for the above-captioned cases are GRANTED. The modifications made to the citations and orders in each docket are set forth below.

KENT 2009-1281

It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8335785, 8335786, 8335790, 8335798, 8335802 and 8335815 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2009-1284

The Secretary has vacated Citation No. 8334581. It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8334580 be MODIFIED to reduce the level of negligence to “low.” It is ORDERED that Citations Nos. 8334590 and 8334599 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2010-9

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8356316 be MODIFIED to change the type of action to a section 104(a) citation, to reduce the level of negligence to “high,” to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2010-10

The Secretary has vacated Citation Nos. 8356307, 8356311, 8356312, 8356313 and 8356315. It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8356291 and 8356292 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2010-148

It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8357224 and 8357241 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2010-152

It is ORDERED that Order Nos. 8356319 and 8356321 be MODIFIED to change the type of action to a section 104(a) citation, to reduce the level of negligence to “moderate,” to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2010-918

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8356561 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2010-1108

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8342695 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding. It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8342697 be MODIFIED to reduce the level of negligence to “moderate.”

KENT 2010-1214

It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8356596 and 8356597 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding. It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8356599 and 8342424 be MODIFIED to reduce the level of negligence to “low.” It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8319991 be MODIFIED to reduce the injury that could reasonably be expected to occur to “lost workdays or restricted duty.” It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8342430 be MODIFIED to reduce the level of negligence to “moderate.” It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8342423, 8342425 and 8342431 be MODIFIED to reduce the numbers of persons affected to “one person.”

KENT 2010-1362

It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8357998, 8365015 and 8365016 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2010-1365

It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8341957 and 8341958 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2010-1516

The Secretary has vacated Citation No. 8364417.

KENT 2010-1518

It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8364049, 8364054, 8364416, 8342450 and 8342451 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding. It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8364050 be MODIFIED to reduce the injury that could reasonably be expected to occur to “lost workdays or restricted duty.” It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8364051 be MODIFIED to reduce the number of persons affected to “three persons.”

KENT 2010-1648

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8357161 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2011-143

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8402886 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2011-144

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8364090 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2011-145

It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8364094, 8364098 and 8364100 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding. It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8364096 and 8364101 be MODIFIED to reduce the number of persons affected to “one person,” and to reduce the injury that could reasonably be expected to occur to “lost workdays or restricted duty.” It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8364099 be MODIFIED to reduce the injury that could reasonably be expected to occur to “lost workdays or restricted duty.”

KENT 2011-156

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8364466 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2011-447

It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8362850 and 8362865 be MODIFIED to reduce the level of negligence to “low.” It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8362859, 8362860 and 8362862 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2011-448

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8364834 be MODIFIED to reduce the level of negligence to “low.” It is ORDERED that Citation No. 9866095 be MODIFIED to reduce the number of persons affected to “two persons,” and to reduce the injury that could reasonably be expected to occur to “lost work days or restricted duty.”

KENT 2011-564

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8342539 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2011-952

It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8365264 and 8365267 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2009-1601

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8354365 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2010-1212

It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8341946 and 8341948 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding, and to reduce the number of persons affected to “one person.”

KENT 2010-1364

It is ORDERED that Order No. 8341930 be MODIFIED to change the type of action to a section 104(a) citation, and to reduce the level of negligence to “high.”

KENT 2010-1649

It is ORDERED that Order No. 8341945 be MODIFIED to change the type of action to a section 104(a) citation, to reduce the level of negligence to “moderate,” and to reduce the number of persons affected to “three persons.”

KENT 2011-154

The Secretary has vacated Order No. 8357976.

KENT 2011-347

It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8363001 and 8363003 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2011-348

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8365032 be MODIFIED to reduce the injury that could reasonably be expected to occur to “lost workdays or restricted duty.”

KENT 2011-559

It is ORDERED that Order No. 8365031 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2011-562

It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8364166, 8364167, 8364169, 8364170, 8364171, 8364173 and 8364174 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding. It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8364163 and 8364164 be MODIFIED to reduce the number of persons affected to “two persons.”

KENT 2011-680

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8335626 be MODIFIED to reduce the level of negligence to “moderate.”

KENT 2011-682

It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8364189, 8364191, 8364192, 8364195, 8364197 and 8346973 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding. It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8364179 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “reasonably likely,” to reduce the number of persons affected to “two persons,” and to reduce the level of negligence to “low.” It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8364190 be MODIFIED to reduce the number of persons affected to “one person.”

KENT 2011-683

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8403194 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding. It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8353222 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding, and to reduce the number of persons affected to “one person.”

KENT 2011-823

It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8353007, 8353009 and 8353012 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding. It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8353008 be MODIFIED to reduce the number of persons affected to “one person.”

KENT 2011-947

It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8364683 and 8353258 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding. It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8353253 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “reasonably likely,” to reduce the injury that could reasonably be expected to occur to “lost workdays,” and to reduce the number of persons affected to “one person.”

KENT 2011-948

The Secretary has vacated Citation No. 8364544.

KENT 2011-949

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8342494 be MODIFIED to reduce the number of persons affected to “one person.”

KENT 2011-950

The Secretary has vacated Citation No. 8365265.

KENT 2011-951

The Secretary has vacated Citation No. 8364542.

KENT 2011-1133

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8363418 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2011-1234

It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8406252, 8365365 and 8406254 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2011-1236

It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8352988, 8352991, 8352992, 8352993, 8352994, 8352995, 8352997, 8352998, 8363702, 8363704, 8363708 and 8363712 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2011-1336

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8362833 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2011-1496

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8365393 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2012-21

It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8368205 and 8368050 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding. It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8368215 and 8368214 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding, and to reduce the number of persons affected to “one person.” It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8363961 be MODIFIED to reduce the number of persons affected to “one person.”

KENT 2012-139

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8368212 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding, and to reduce the level of negligence to “moderate.”

KENT 2012-140

It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8362855 and 8362885 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2012-141

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8363415 be MODIFIED to reduce the number of persons affected to “two persons.” It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8406272 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2012-320

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8352990 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2012-321

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8365368 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “reasonably likely,” and to reduce the level of negligence to “moderate.” It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8405748 be MODIFIED to reduce the number of persons affected to “one person.”

KENT 2012-322

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8363431 be MODIFIED to reduce the level of negligence to “moderate.” It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8406477 be MODIFIED to reduce the number of persons affected to “one person,” and to reduce the level of negligence to “moderate.”

KENT 2012-847

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8368247 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2012-848

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8365678 be MODIFIED to change the type of action to a section 104(a) citation, and to reduce the level of negligence to “moderate.”

KENT 2012-974

The Secretary has vacated Citation No. 8378202. It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8378201 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2012-22

The Secretary has vacated Citation No. 8406503. It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8353911 be MODIFIED to reduce the number of persons affected to “two persons.”

KENT 2012-726

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8368451 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2012-728

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8363458 be MODIFIED to reduce the level of negligence to “moderate.” It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8353919 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “reasonably likely.”

KENT 2012-885

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8406496 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2009-1388

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8335351 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2010-1515

It is ORDERED that Order No. 8341943 be MODIFIED to change the type of action to a section 104(a) action, to reduce the likelihood of injury to “reasonably likely,” and to reduce the number of persons affected to “two persons.”

KENT 2010-1517

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8364000 be MODIFIED to change the type of action to a section 104(a) action, and to reduce the likelihood of injury to “reasonably likely.” It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8364002 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2011-349

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8342515 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2011-561

It is ORDERED that Order No. 8403810 be MODIFIED to change the type of action to a section 104(a) citation, and to reduce the number of persons affected to “one person.” It is ORDERED that Order No. 8403811 be MODIFIED to change the type of action to a section 104(a) citation, and to reduce the level of negligence to “moderate.”

KENT 2011-681

It is ORDERED that Order No. 8403813 be MODIFIED to change the type of action to a section 104(a) citation, and to reduce the level of negligence to “high.”

KENT 2011-1132

It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8364680 and 8364681 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “reasonably likely,” and to reduce the injury that could reasonably be expected to occur to “lost workdays.” It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8353256, 8353267, 8353286 and 8352978 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2011-1237

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8363428 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2011-1334

It is ORDERED that Order No. 8342516 be MODIFIED to reduce the injury that could reasonably be expected to occur to “no lost workdays.”

KENT 2011-1495

It is ORDERED that Order No. 8364181 be MODIFIED to change the type of action to a section 104(a) citation, and to reduce the number of persons to “two persons.” It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8364194 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding, and to reduce the number of persons to “one person.”

KENT 2011-1498

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8363460 be MODIFIED to reduce the level of negligence to “moderate.” It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8353925 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding,

KENT 2012-20

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8347842 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding. It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8406122 be MODIFIED to reduce the number of persons affected to “one person.”

KENT 2012-23

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8342546 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “reasonably likely,” and to reduce the injury that could reasonably be expected to occur to “lost work days.” It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8342557 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely,” and to remove the inspector’s significant and substantial finding.

KENT 2012-414

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8368064 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “reasonably likely.”

KENT 2012-725

The Secretary has vacated Citation No. 8368218. It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8368065, 8368213 and 8368054 be MODIFIED to change the type of action to a section 104(a) citation, to reduce the level of negligence to “moderate,” and to reduce the likelihood of injury to “reasonably likely.” It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8368219 be MODIFIED to reduce the level of negligence to “high,” and to reduce the likelihood of injury to “reasonably likely.” It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8368220 be MODIFIED to change the type of action to a section 104(a) citation, to reduce the level of negligence to “high,” and to reduce the likelihood of injury to “reasonably likely.”

KENT 2012-841

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8406504 be MODIFIED to change the type of action to a section 104(a) citation, and to reduce the likelihood of injury to “unlikely.” It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8353920 be MODIFIED to change the type of action to a section 104(a) citation, and to reduce the injury that could reasonably be expected to occur to “lost workdays.” It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8353935 be MODIFIED to reduce the injury that could reasonably be expected to occur to “lost workdays.”

KENT 2012-846

It is ORDERED that Citation No. 8368063 be MODIFIED to change the type of action to a section 104(a) citation, to reduce the level of negligence to “moderate,” and to reduce the likelihood of injury to “reasonably likely.” It is ORDERED that Citation Nos. 8368051 and 8368217 be MODIFIED to reduce the likelihood of injury to “reasonably likely.”

KENT 2010-1213

It is ORDERED that Order No. 8364001 be MODIFIED to reduce the injury or illness that could reasonably be expected to occur to “permanently disabling” and to reduce the level of negligence to “moderate.”

PAYMENT

It is further ORDERED that the operator pay a total penalty of $1,197,365.00

in ten installments. The first payment in the amount of $119,736.50 will be due on July 24, 2013.  Nine subsequent payments of $119,736.50 shall be due on the following dates: August 24, 2013, September 24, 2013, October 24, 2013, November 24, 2013, December 24, 2013,

January 24, 2014, February 24, 2014, March 24, 2014 and April 24, 2014. 

The parties have agreed that failure to make any of the scheduled payments within ten days of the due date will result in the entire, unpaid balance becoming immediately due and payable, together with such court costs as may be incurred by the U.S. Department of Labor, or other agency acting on its behalf, in collecting the amount due.  Upon receipt of full payment, the above-captioned cases are DISMISSED.

/s/ David F. Barbour

David F. Barbour

Administrative Law Judge

Distribution:

Amanda K. Slater, Office of the Solicitor, U.S. Department of Labor, 1999 Broadway,

Suite 800, Denver, CO 80202-5708

Schean G. Belton, Office of the Solicitor, U.S. Department of Labor, 618 Church Street,

Suite 230, Nashville, TN 37219

John Williams, Esq., Rajkovich, Williams,Kilpatrick & True, PLLC, 3151 Beaumont Centre Circle, Suite 375, Lexington, KY 40513

Benjamin Bennett, President, Manalapan Mining Co., Inc., 10156 U.S. Highway 25E, Pineville, KY 40988

Jim Brummett, Manalapan Mining Co., Inc., 8174 East Highway 72, Pathfork, KY 40863

/ca; /dm

---

^[1] Hilda L. Solis resigned as Secretary of Labor on January 22, 2013. Deputy Secretary Seth D. Harris is the Acting Secretary of Labor.

[2] Docket Nos. KENT 2010-1651, KENT 2012-972 and KENT 2012-973, originally consolidated under lead Docket No. KENT 2009-1097, settled before the global settlement conference. The court dismissed these cases in prior Decisions Approving Settlement.

In addition to the cases originally consolidated under lead Docket No. KENT 2009-1097, the parties also discussed Docket Nos. KENT 2012-1394, KENT 2012-1499, KENT 2012-1501, KENT 2013-17, KENT 2013-18 and KENT 2013-352 during the settlement conference. These dockets are part of the global settlement submitted to the court and, accordingly, are included in the caption.